--- tags: - decisions --- # Decision Log Newest at the bottom. Status is one of: **accepted**, **proposed**, **rejected**, **superseded**. ## Phased time model with a fixed-step simulation - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** accepted - **Context:** rounds are a paused planning phase followed by a real-time wave ([[Game Constraints]]). - **Decision:** a fixed 60 Hz `SimClock` (pausable, speed via extra steps) and a separate real-time `FrameClock` for UI; interpolated rendering. - **Consequences:** planning is just speed 0; combat stays stable at every speed. See [[Main Loop and Time]]. ## Seeded run generation, non-deterministic combat - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** accepted - **Decision:** named RNG streams with our own distributions; no requirement for combat to replay bit-exactly. - **Consequences:** floats are allowed in the simulation, and there's no lockstep constraint. See [[Randomness]]. ## Grid with fixed lanes - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** accepted - **Decision:** enemies follow predefined lanes; towers are placed on buildable tiles and never block paths. - **Consequences:** no pathfinding system; lane following is a waypoint or spline walk. ## Rigid-part 3D on SDL_GPU - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** accepted - **Context:** we want 3D presentation without the engine and art cost of skeletal animation. - **Decision:** render with SDL_GPU (not SDL_Renderer); models are rigid node hierarchies animated by glTF node clips plus procedural overrides; a `Renderer2D` overlay for the UI. - **Consequences:** a shader build step (SPIR-V, Vulkan on Linux and Windows); instancing from the start; skinning deferred. See [[Rendering]], [[Rigid-Part Animation]]. ## The simulation stays 2D - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** accepted - **Decision:** gameplay positions are 2D on the ground plane; height is visual only. - **Consequences:** gameplay code and scripts are unaffected by the 3D presentation. ## C# not used for scripting - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** rejected - **Reason:** CoreCLR hosting, an interop layer, fragile hot reload and runtime distribution cost too much for event-only content hooks. It would only fit as the main game language, which isn't the goal. ## Scripting language shortlist - **Date:** 2026-09-23 · **Status:** proposed - **Decision:** the candidates are Lua (5.4 or Luau) and AngelScript, to be decided by a spike. See [[Scripting]]. ## Error handling split - **Date:** 2026-09-24 · **Status:** accepted - **Context:** principle 6 of the [[Engine Overview]] ("errors as values") was written for loaders, then stretched to platform startup. There, it forced static `Create()` factories, private constructors, and move constructors with a "moved-from" flag, just to return non-movable things like the SDL context through `std::expected`. - **Decision:** errors you can recover from are values; fatal errors are exceptions. - `std::expected` for failures the caller really handles on the spot: loading assets, compiling scripts, parsing definitions. The caller falls back and keeps running, which hot reload depends on. - Exceptions (`std::runtime_error` for now) for failures with nothing to fall back to: SDL/window/GPU startup, broken invariants. Thrown from constructors and caught once in `main`, which logs and exits with 1. - **Consequences:** platform types are plain RAII classes: a constructor that throws, non-movable when they mean "exactly one" (`SdlContext`, `Window`), and no empty state. The STL throws anyway, so `-fno-exceptions` was never an option. Exceptions must not cross C callbacks (SDL, the script VM): script bindings need a catch boundary. ## Catch2 v3 for unit tests - **Date:** 2026-09-25 · **Status:** accepted - **Context:** we needed a framework for `siege_tests`; the candidates were doctest and Catch2 v3. - **Decision:** Catch2 v3, pinned to the nixpkgs version like every other dependency. Tests live in `Tests/`, mirroring `Source/`. - **Reason:** doctest's main advantage (tests inline in production `.cpp` files) doesn't work well with `siege_engine` being a static library: the linker drops test-only object files unless the whole archive is force-linked. Catch2's generators suit the RNG and property tests we'll need, its floating-point matchers suit the clocks and simulation, it has built-in benchmarks, and it's actively maintained. Compile time is a non-issue at this size, with the PCH. - **Consequences:** `catch_discover_tests` registers each `TEST_CASE` with ctest. Slow tests are tagged `[slow]`.